Looking Beyond the Headlines: A Conversation About School Improvement
Please read the following message from Interim Superintendent Jennifer Botzojorns, originally shared with KESD staff and submitted to the Caledonian-Record as an editorial contribution.
My Turn
When I was a child, report card day brought: excitement, worry, pride, frustration, curiosity. The emotion depended on the year, season, school and teacher. I carried it home, in my bag which sat on my lap as I rode the school bus. Then I placed it on the dinner table. After the meal the half-sized manilla envelope was opened. Then came the conversation. This varied as did the marks, but always, in the end, “we” made some sort of plan for my “improvement.” This sometimes involved stacking firewood.
This memory is jogged because the Vermont Agency of Education will soon release school “report cards.” These have been shared, prior to public knowledge, with school leaders and are embargoed -- we are not able to share our results, discussions and improvement plans until the reports are officially released.
The headlines these days seem to be that our schools are doing terribly. We also know there are influencing factors that we navigate as the culture, backdrop and narratives change. One interesting part of the statewide assessment “VTCAP” is the assessment grades students in a specific way. This is different from how the state assessed students 5 years ago which is different from the assessment 12 years ago. (It will change again next year). In addition, we are required to use local assessments to understand student learning. For a simple example: on the statewide assessment a child is graded on whether they can multiply 4 x 4 x 8 on a screen with a keyboard- using a computer. In a classroom they are asked to show what the area is, in cubic feet, of a 4 x 4 x 8 stack of firewood (show your work, label your answer).
The statewide assessment is based on state communicated “prioritized standards” -- what topics are the most important (and will be tested). The most recent priorities were published and then taken down (archived) on the Vermont Agency of Education website and then recently republished (except the math which is still not published). So, as we plan for improvement, the landscape keeps adjusting.
Don’t get me wrong -- I know we have work to do to improve, in many areas, in all of our schools. Every faculty and staff member in every school is working to improve student outcomes. The work forward is together and with a plan -- I invite all of us, as we look at the “report cards,” to ask - what we need to do (in the context of the many state and federal rules and changing landscape) to support student achievement and school improvement.
We are a community and welcome this discussion. A discussion just as we may have had years ago, as described above, at the family dinner table.
Jennifer Botzojorns
Interim Superintendent of Schools








